If you’ve started getting some odd unsightly staining on your teeth and it just keeps on getting darker, then it’s time you do something ASAP. Your regular toothpaste might wipe out the germs and bacteria but scraping off that yellowish tinge might be a problem.
Fortunately, with the availability of teeth whitening toothpastes on the market, you don’t even have to drain your bank account or necessarily visit a dentist to restore your teeth to their former glory. However, the number of varieties from similar to different brands is quite staggering. Trying to decipher the ones that work and ones that don’t is not just challenging but can be seriously time consuming.
In a bid to help you narrow the list down to the best product, we’ve taken a closer look at the various options and came up with a list of five whitening toothpastes that we believe can really deliver results. Ingredients used, their effectiveness, taste, texture and of course price are the key checkpoints we employed in our selection. We’ve ranked and included a brief review of each product with their strengths and weaknesses, which we hope you will find highly helpful when making your decision.
So, without further delay, let’s begin,
Our Top 5 Picks:
Although its whitening ability is not that intense like other whitening toothpastes in this list, it’s still capable of removing tough stains or plaque from the teeth and polish it. The key whitening component is a mild abrasive, hydrated silica, and works hand in hand with sodium hydroxide which is a whitener. That combination though not the most powerful is effective and can restore the natural white look of the teeth.
Alleviating sensitivity is the area that the Sensodyne ProNamel Gentle excels best. And the components that make this possible are potassium nitrate in combination with sodium fluoride. However, same to whitening the teeth, sensitivity relief does not take place over night, it builds up with continue use but you can notice the difference after a week or so.
The sodium fluoride ion also protects the teeth from potential cavity. Much more interesting is that it also combats erosion of tooth enamel by acids in the food which can cause further sensitivity. The fluoride ion restores the lost minerals hence re-hardens the acid-softened enamel.
In terms of taste, the toothpaste has a pleasant light minty flavour and can keep your breath fresh for hours. The price is not at par with other whitening toothpastes on the market, it’s slightly higher. Even so, considering the advantages it bags, it’s worth it.
All things taken into account, I can say the only mishap is the fact that not much attention has been given in the whitening process, but nonetheless the formulation is gradually effective. Where it beats the rest though is relieving sensitivity. So, if you are in the market for a gentle whitening toothpaste for your sensitive teeth, then you can start first by considering this Sensodyne ProNamel Gentle whitening toothpaste.
- Gentle on the teeth
- Somewhat effective in cleaning the teeth
- Protects the enamel from acid erosion
- Prevents cavities
- Pleasant flavour
- Its whitening power isn’t the strongest
Aside from Opalescence, Tom’s of Maine Antiplaque and Whitening toothpaste is the only other whitening toothpaste in our list that employs all natural ingredients in its formulation. It’s fluoride-free and does not use any artificial flavours, sweeteners, dyes or preservatives.
This toothpaste combines three whitening ingredients, hydrated silica, calcium carbonate, and sodium carbonate. All these three ingredients are naturally sourced abrasives but, be that as it may, nothing about their results is mild. They perform a thorough cleansing and polishing on the teeth surface and with time they can remove stubborn stains that make the teeth appear brown or yellowish.
Along with being able to restore that shinny toothy grin, these ingredients are not harsh on the teeth. In place of fluoride ion, Tom’s of Maine uses zinc citrate derived from natural occurring zinc mineral to fight off cavities. If you are not a fan of fluorides, then this natural anti-cavity ingredient might do fine for you.
Moving on, the texture is somehow unusual, so it needs some getting used to. However the mild peppermint flavour with a mix of xylitol sweetener sourced from birch trees or corn has a pleasant taste which is impressive given that this toothpaste does not utilize any artificial dye.
Since all the ingredients are naturally sourced, this toothpaste can be used by almost everyone in the family, including children below the age of 12.
There is no major drawback noted with this Tom’s of Maine’s antiplaque and whitening toothpaste but the price tag is $5 to $10 higher than the average toothpaste. So, if you are on a tight-budget, you will need to do some re-adjustments to fit it in.
To sum it all, this toothpaste is a great buy if you prefer or need an all-natural, organic toothpaste that can help to clean and maintain the whiteness of your teeth.
- Effective all-natural whitening ingredients
- Addresses other common dental issues
- Pleasant taste with a unique texture
- Safe for use by everyone including children
- Not commonly available in retail drug stores
The toothpaste combines 0.25% hydrogen peroxide and 0.25% sodium fluoride with 5.0% potassium nitrate as active ingredients. Hydrogen peroxide, in particular, is a powerful bleaching agent capable of producing excellent results over a short period of time. That small dose in Opalescence can remove any lingering stains on and below the teeth surface.
So, as far as keeping your teeth as white as possible is concerned, the Opalescence is quite reliable and with regular use, it can deliver some major differences in a matter of weeks.
Considering that most whitening ingredients including hydrogen peroxide often cause mild sensitivity, this toothpaste is somewhat gentle on the teeth and that’s because of the potassium nitrate and sodium chloride. They help keep the enamel protected from unwanted cavities. Thus, chances of experiencing sensitivity with this paste are very low.
Another thing to like about the Opalescence is that it’s not too runny like most other whitening toothpastes, it’s more of a thick gel than a regular paste. However, if you are not a fan of mint, you might not like the cool minty flavour it comes with but nonetheless, it’s a nice addition that keeps off bad breath. It’s actually close to wintergreen mint, so it’s somewhat tasty and not that bitter.
One slight setback though with the Opalescence is that you can only use it for a short period of time as per your convenience. Prolonged use can wear down the enamel and probably damage your dental work.
All in all, along with improving your teeth appearance, the Opalescence whitening toothpaste addresses an array of dental issues such as fighting cavities and removing plaque. The price might be a bit higher but it’s an effective product that’s worth a try.
- Low Abrasion formula to prevent cavities
- Keeps the teeth as white as possible
- Mint flavour for fresh breath
- Safe for all ages
- Not ideal for prolonged use
- Can wear down enamel
Colgate is a very reputable and popular brand in the dental hygiene market with most of its toothpastes always securing a place in many shoppers’ list. However, in its range of whitening toothpastes, the Optic White series takes the upper hand.
First, let’s take care of the elephant in the room. The Optic White does not deliver visible results within three days as promised on the package. So, if you are after a faster whitening toothpaste, I’m afraid this won’t give you that. However, the Optic White has a strong whitening formulation compared to other whitening toothpastes. It might not deliver faster results as promised but it’s very effective with regular use and that’s what propels it to the second spot in our list.
Its main whitening ingredient is hydrogen peroxide, and like I mentioned earlier, this is a powerful stain removing agent with some bit of whitening effects. Basically, you can expect your teeth to get a few shades lighter after a week or two but full visible results might be after one month of consistent use.
The Optic White also does a good job of protecting the teeth from any further stain build-up. In addition to hydrogen peroxide, the formulation features disodium pyrophosphate and tetrasodium pyrophosphate, two tartar control ingredients that help keep stain at bay. So, it does lighten the teeth and help keep them that way.
Like a lot of other toothpastes, the Optic White has a fluoride component as one of its active ingredient to protect the teeth from cavities.
Eliminating bad breath is another strong feature of this toothpaste. A good number of toothpastes only freshen your breath for about two to three hours, but the Optic White goes for up to 12 hours and that’s because it has a very strong minty flavour. Unfortunately, while that’s a big bonus, the taste is somehow off putting.
Another major point of concern is that it’s a bit sensitive on the teeth, mainly due to the strong minty flavour and the hydrogen peroxide. Nevertheless, in terms of whitening the teeth it has passed the test. The packaging looks classy too.
Generally, if you are working on a tight budget but you want proven performance, then Colgate Optic White is an ideal choice. It comes in a variety of options whereby you can choose according to your preference.
- It’s very effective but a bit slow
- Can give long-lasting results
- Protects the teeth from cavities
- A variety of Options to choose from
- It’s somewhat affordable
- Uses artificial ingredients as well as flavourings
- Has a very strong minty taste
Crest is another reputable brand in the dental hygiene market with a variety of whitening toothpastes under its name. However, its Crest 3D White Luxe Glamorous is particularly the most effective stain removing toothpaste in the market.
Again I should state the facts here, Crest 3D White Luxe Glamorous claims to remove 90% of all stains on the teeth within just two days, that’s not quite the case. It isn’t that fast but it will still do it quicker than the rest. One thing I agree is that this is the most effective toothpaste out there and can give a more dramatic results within a very short period of time though certainly not two days.
Like the Optic White, Crest 3D White Luxe Glamorous combines three whitening ingredients, that is, hydrated silica, sodium hydroxide and disodium pyrophosphate. This powerful formulation is capable of delivering optimal whitening results within a few weeks with noticeable results expected to take place after only one week.
The best part of Crest 3D White Luxe Glamorous is that unlike other toothpastes which just polish the surface of the teeth, this toothpaste creates a foaming action that penetrates hard-to-reach places, so it provides a holistic cleansing. Another thumbs up for the Crest 3D White Luxe Glamorous is its exclusive Whitelock technology, which like the Colgate Optic White keeps away future stains from forming.
Apart from its whitening abilities, Crest 3D White provides anti-cavity benefit as it also features fluoride, though that is pretty common to all toothpastes. The texture is no different to other Crest products but the minty fresh flavour is a nice addition in the mix as it helps to keep your breath fresh for a long time.
It’s worth to note that there have been several concerns that the Crest 3D whitening toothpaste may cause sensitivity after a few weeks of use. However, despite these concerns, most people seemed pleased with how effective it is in when it comes to whitening the teeth especially when combined with the crest whitening mouthwash.
Overall, given its price and effectiveness of its formulation, Crest 3D White Luxe Glamorous whitening toothpaste indeed offers great value. If none of the above choices managed to win you over then this might do.
- Most effective whitening formulation
- Full visible results within a short period of time
- Tasteful fresh mint flavour
- Fights cavities and expels bad breath
- Not suitable for children under 12 years
- May cause stomach-aches
Slightly higher price
Best Whitening Toothpaste – The Bottom Line
There are many whitening toothpastes in the market, each designed to give some level of whitening effect and address some certain dental issues. Pairing a reliable toothpaste with the right brushing technique can make a big difference not only to the color of your teeth but also to your dental health.
The above toothpastes proves to be the most effective and capable of accommodating diverse users, those with sensitive teeth to those who are specifically looking for organic whitening ingredients.
So, if you were overwhelmed with the number of options in the market, I believe now you stand a better chance to pick an option that will address all your needs.